When my husband and I first started dating (over 8 years ago), his family would always buy a peanut butter pie from a local restaurant. After a few years, the restaurant stopped selling it and I began a mission to try and duplicate it. After years of testing, trying and enjoying peanut butter pies I finally think it's perfect! And of course it's given me plenty of time to put my own twist on it. I've made this several times into small pies instead of a large one and it's perfect because everyone gets their own individual pie! Plus they can be individualized if someone doesn't want certain garnishes on top.
Currently, this is visible to site members only. Before we can submit your to the public gallery, we’ll need to change the privacy settings of your to allow everyone a chance to see it.
If you’d like to proceed, click Continue and we’ll automatically change the setting for you.
Currently, this is visible to site members only. Before you can share your , we’ll need to change the privacy settings of your to allow everyone a chance to see it.
If you’d like to proceed, click Continue and we’ll automatically change the setting for you.
Click on a group below to send your . Once you select a group, your will be sent automatically. When you’ve finished, click done.
LOGIN DAILY FOR YOUR CHANCE TO WIN!
login now
/recipes?query=strawberry
/recipes?query=banana
/recipes?query=peanut+butter
/recipes?query=chocolate
/recipes?query=peach
/recipes?query=egg
/recipes?query=lemon
/recipes?query=walnut
/recipes?query=spinach
/recipes?query=tomato
/recipes/2?query=honey
/recipes?query=apple
/recipes?query=basil
/recipes?query=chickenthink
/recipes?query=coconut
/recipes?query=pear
/recipes?query=beef
/recipes/2?query=shrimp
/recipes?query=raspberry
/recipes?query=asparagus
/recipes?query=broccoli
/recipes?query=avocado
/recipes?query=onion
/recipes?query=potato
/recipes?query=carrot
/recipes?query=pumpkin
/recipes?query=squash
/recipes?query=corn
/recipes/2?query=white%20chocolate
/recipes?query=cinnamon
/recipes?query=orange
/recipes?query=bell%20pepper
/recipes?query=zucchini
/recipes?query=bacon
/recipes?query=mushroom
/recipes?query=artichoke
/recipes?query=garlic
/recipes?query=pineapple
/recipes?query=Cherry
/recipes?query=marshmallow
/recipes?query=hot+sauce
/recipes?query=blueberry
/recipes?query=vanilla
/recipes?query=pesto
/recipes?query=coffee
/recipes?query=pasta
/recipes/view/1785075/roasted-cream-cheese-anglecot-cherry-berry-cobbler
/recipes/view/2123934/kalamata-amp-cream-cheese-turkey-burgers-with-sundried-tomato-spread
/recipes/view/2113247/green-chile-and-cheese-chip-dip
/recipes/view/2127341/chocolate-indulgence-wontons
/recipes/view/1068347/creamy-corn-filled-tomatoes
/recipes/view/1803384/surprise-me-coconut-vanilla-cream-tart
/recipes/view/2126809/macaroni-and-cheese
/recipes/view/2092577/cheesy-savory-garlic-grilled-green-bean-skillet
/recipes/view/2534927/to-die-for-chocolate-torte
/recipes/view/2081521/creamy-broccoli-chicken-pasta
/recipes?query=marshmallow
/recipes?query=hot+sauce
/recipes?query=blueberry
/recipes?query=vanilla
/recipes?query=pesto
/recipes?query=coffee
/recipes?query=pasta
Join the Discussion!